The Best Car Floor Mats of 2024 - Tested by Our Expert

There’s a HUGE difference between a "good car mat" and the "best car floor mat", would you agree?

So many brands sell us on their "cutting-edge" custom car mats with a cool name or ultra-specific features, and whatnot, making us feel we made the right choice.

At some point, you decide to test those car floor mats in an unusual scenario like a trip to a highly snowy region, or a muddy forest and the "good car mats" reveal being useless.

It’s only ironic that the best car floor mats that truly protect your car interior and makes car cleaning much easier, is the one that makes you "Pay more to spend less".

Yes, you need to test a lot of car floor mats to find these gems (and some could be expensive). But we did that work for you. This article is the result of testing dozens of car floor mats with different engineering, prices, safety features, and customer service.

To help you find the best one for your needs, we have compiled a list of the 7 best car mats that will help you keep your car clean and protected (including ours: WeatherTech Car Mats).

💡 For you: Order Your Set of WeatherTech Car Mats and Protect Your Car

Car floor mats comparison chart

1. WeatherTech Custom Fit Floorliners

WeatherTech custom-fit floor mats are 3D-designed and laser-measured to fit your vehicle model as good as possible. Plus, WeatherTech car mats are made of TPE material, which is designed to protect your car from heavy snow, lots of water, and sticky mud.

WeatherTech floor mats are designed to a high standard of safety to prevent your accelerator and brake pedals from getting stuck in the mat.

These made-in-USA floor mats are perfect if you have a busy family with busy lives who don't have time to spend every week cleaning their car floors of heavy dirt, liquids, and mud.

WeatherTech car mats are also a big win for drivers who enjoy a clean and beautiful interior. After all, our car mats are designed with utility and beauty in mind.

Below we go over an introduction to WeatherTech car floor mats.

An introduction to the benefits and advantages of WeatherTech Car Floor Mats

Note: Do you need to know how to install WeatherTech car floor mats? Check out our 13-minute video which shows you how to install our aftermaket car floor mats.

What's so special about WeatherTech Floor Mats?

WeatherTech Floor Mats are custom-fit

WeatherTech car floor mats undergo precise laser measurements to guarantee a perfect fit for every vehicle.

At WeatherTech We Follow Safety Regulations

Extensive research and testing are conducted by our WeatherTech team to ensure the car mats meet safety standards and regulations, with a focus on quality control and adherence to R&D guidelines. Incorrectly fitted floor mats contribute to hundreds of crashes each year, and at WeatherTech we work to avoid this. Our floor mats and floor liners undergo rigorous testing to meet or exceed industry safety standards.

WeatherTech Car Mats are Made with Durable Material

Our car floor mats are designed for durability, using high-quality TPE materials that resist damage and are easy to clean due to their raised edges.

Ease of Use

WeatherTech car mats are made for easy installation and removal, with simple instructions and user-friendly features. You can check our 13-minute long installation guide.

Fast Shipping

WeatherTechCH guarantees shipping within 5 to 10 business days if we have them in stock in Switzerland. If you order custom-fit floor mats for a more unusual vehicle model, delivery will be within 4-6 weeks.

Customer Reviews 

At the time of writing, WeatherTechCH has 66 reviews on our website with a star rating of 4.6 out of 5. 

As you can see below, reviewers specifically mention WeatherTech's "Perfect Fit” when compared to other car floor mats.

Pricing

Weathertech top-quality material, advanced engineering, and a strict safety regulation must be paid somehow.

• First Row: WeatherTech front row floor mats start from CHF 149.95.

• Second Row: Our custom-fit floor mats for a 2nd row start from CHF 99.95.

• Cargo Liner: WeatherTech cargo mats start from CHF159.95 for a Tesla Model 3 boot.

A quick yet important note about "how to choose your car floor mats": We see a relatively high number of customers who order a set of car mats and select the wrong car model. For example, if you need custom fit mats for Toyota Prius XW60, they would be different from the car mats for a Toyota Prius XW30. Therefore, we strongly recommend that you contact us by email if you have any doubts about your car model. This would ensure you a smoother buying process.

💡 Discover the best all-weather car floor mats

Recommended WeatherTech all-weather floor mats:

• Mercedes V-Class - this vehicle is so recognisable as the go-to people transporter.

• The New Toyota Highlander XU70 - the super cool SUV that breaks into the European market with style and a dash of innovation.

• Audi Q4 - one of the ground breaking EMV from Audi, that still turns-heads, but offers flexible usage.

• Kia EV9 - who doesn't want fast recharging, cool design and 180 degree rotating 2nd row seats!

2. Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Mats

Smartliner Custom Fit Floor Liners are cost-effective, durable, and aesthetically pleasing. These all-season mats are tailored to fit perfectly in any car without the high cost, ideal for drivers looking to protect their car from the elements (and children).

Pros of Smartliner Car Mats

• Custom Fit: These car floor mats will usually fit perfectly on any car model leaving almost no gaps, even on those specific models that have recently been updated.

• Good perceived quality: Smartliner car mats look nice and seem to be made of good-quality material.

Cons of Smartliner Car Mats

• Not all batches fit perfectly: While researching on the Internet, we found that some batches of Smarliner floor liners didn't fit perfectly in the car. It's hard to understand why. It could be due to the customer's poor purchasing decision or because the mats are not custom-made for each car model.

• Moving around: Some customers have reported that the liners slip around without the carpet clips.

• Slow delivery: We could experience a slow delivery when the order was managed by some specific couriers.

3. Motor Trend FlexTough

Motor Trend, known for its magazine and television shows, also offers a line of car accessories, including their FlexTough rubber floor mats. These mats aim to provide a better protection than your factory car floor carpet without the premium price tag of some competitors.

Pros of Motor Trend FlexTough Floor Liners

• Universal Trim: Motor Trend FlexTough rubber car mats are designed to fit a wide range of vehicles, making them a convenient option for those who may switch cars frequently or want a quick and easy solution.

• Multiple Color Options: You have up to 6 colors to choose from (beige, gray, black, brown, burgundy, cobalt blue).

• 2'' Deep Dish Design: This will help you trap SOME water and dust.

Cons of Motor Trend FlexTough Floor Liners

• Just good enough: These car mats will stand occasional dirt, and snow of milder climates. But they will not work for the salt, snow, slush, and mud of those regions with more extreme water.

• Universal trim: Motor Trend FlexTough floor mats will withstand the occasional dirt and snow of milder climates. But they will not work for the salt, snow, slush, and mud of those regions with more extreme water.

• Missing side wall: This leaves the carpet surrounding the mats exposed to dirt and salt.

💡 Discover the best floor mats for your Tesla Model 3

4. Husky Liners Weatherbeater

Husky Liners have tall walls and a secure design to protect your vehicle's flooring from dirt and moisture, even when faced with heavy use or messy kids.

Pros of Husky Weatherbeater Floor Liners

• Perfect Fit: Husky Liners uses FormFit Design™ which is their laser scanning technology to create mats that precisely match the contours of your vehicle's floor. This ensures a secure fit and prevents any gaps where dirt and moisture could seep through.

• StayPut Nibs™ for Enhanced Safety: The underside of Husky Weatherbeaters features StayPut Nibs™, small spikes that grip the carpet and prevent the mats from shifting or sliding. This enhances safety by ensuring the mats don't interfere with the pedals.

• Raised Edges and Channels for Spill Containment: Husky Weatherbeaters have raised edges and strategically placed channels that effectively contain spills, mud, and other debris.

Cons of Husky Weatherbeater floor liners

• More complicated to install.

• Some car liners took a few days to lay flat and were curling around the edges.

• The cargo liner took a few days to lay flat and was curling around the edges.

5. Armor All Weather Defender Floor Mats

These mats offer an affordable solution to shield your car's interior from low-intensity dirt, spills, and elements. Featuring a trim-to-fit design and patented Carpet Claw anti-skid technology, they provide a secure and customizable fit for various vehicles.

Pros of Armor All Weather Defender Floor Mats

• Trim-to-Fit Versatility: Armor All Weather Defender mats can be easily trimmed with scissors to fit a wide range of vehicles.

• Patented Carpet Claw Anti-Skid Technology: The mats feature a unique Carpet Claw design on the underside that grips the carpet and prevents it from shifting or sliding, enhancing safety and stability.

• Easy to Clean: The smooth surface of the mats makes them easy to clean with a simple wipe-down or hose-off.

Cons of Armor All Weather Defender Floor Mats

May Not Fit Perfectly: While the trim-to-fit design offers flexibility, achieving a truly precise fit can be challenging, and some users have reported gaps or overhangs after trimming.

Not Ideal for Extreme Conditions: As they're universal floor mats, Armor All Weather Defender may not offer the same level of protection as those with higher sidewalls and more specialized designs, particularly in areas with heavy snow or rain.

💡Check the best Custom-Fit Floor Mats

6. Rough Country Floor Liners

Rough Country, a well-known name in off-roading and truck accessories, also offers a line of durable floor mats designed to withstand tough conditions.

Pros of Rough Country Floor Liners

Durable and Rugged Construction: Rough Country floor liners are made from a high-quality, injection-molded thermoplastic material designed to withstand even the toughest conditions.

Deep Tread Design for Maximum Protection: The liners feature a deep tread pattern with raised edges and channels that effectively trap dirt, mud, snow, and spills.

Custom Fit for a Secure Fit: Rough Country offers vehicle-specific floor liners designed to precisely fit the contours of your car's floor.

Cons of Armor Rough Country floor mats

Occasional Fit Issues: While Rough Country emphasizes a custom fit, some customer reviews mention occasional inconsistencies with fitment.

Limited Color Options: Rough Country floor liners are typically available in black, which may not match all car interiors or satisfy those seeking more customization options.

💡 Discover how to choose the best car mats for your car

How did we choose these floor liners and car mats?

We've created a detailed guide on selecting car mats, so we understand what to consider when purchasing. These are the features we evaluate when making our list of the best car floor mats:

Custom-fit

I encountered a stuck accelerator pedal due to car mats but switched to a safer option. We verify that these mats are compatible with popular car models.

Safety Regulations

Overlooking safety regulations can have serious consequences on your driving. That's the reason why we try to find as many information as possible on the safety regulations that each car floor mats' brand is following.

Ease of Use

Car mats are meant to simplify your life, not complicate it. Ease of use is a crucial factor to consider when making your selection of floor mats. That's the reason why we ensure that these floor mats are designed in a way to give you the best use experience while in your vehicle.

💡 For you: Order Your Set of WeatherTech Car Mats and Protect Your Car

Frequently asked questions about the best car floor mats

Universal Fit vs. Custom Fit Car Floor Mats

Custom-fit floor mats are laser-measured for specific vehicle models, providing complete coverage and secure attachment. Universal fit mats are designed to fit multiple vehicles but offer less protection due to generic sizing and may require trimming. Custom-fit mats typically cost 30-50% more but provide superior protection and safety features.

What floor mats are as good as WeatherTech?

Two floor mat brands match Weathertech's quality standards:

• Husky Liners Weatherbeater - Offers lifetime warranty and comparable fluid containment

• Smartliner Custom Fit - Provides similar precision fit at lower cost

Are thicker car mats better?

Thicker car mats provide superior durability, enhanced comfort, and better moisture absorption. They offer improved protection against wear and tear but may cost more and be harder to clean. The ideal thickness depends on usage patterns and climate conditions.

Are rubber car mats better than fabric?

Rubber car mats are superior for durability and protection, offering:

• Better water resistance

• Easier cleaning (quick hose-down)

• Enhanced durability

• Superior spill protection

However, fabric mats provide better aesthetics and comfort underfoot.

 

💡 Order Your Set of WeatherTech Car Mats and Protect Your Car